Traditional Cel Animation

The production process of Bread Will Walk was rooted in the principles of traditional hand-drawn animation despite employing a contemporary hybrid pipeline. Rather than replacing drawing with digital image generation or three-dimensional production, the film treated digital tools as successive layers built upon an entirely hand-animated foundation. The resulting workflow reflects a long tradition within animation history in which new technologies are incorporated without replacing the central role of the animator’s drawing.

The project originated as a conventional ink-on-paper production. Before textures, compositing or digital treatments were introduced, the entire film existed as hand-drawn animation. Alex Boya completed approximately 4,000 individual ink drawings, animated straight ahead on paper before any colouring or photographic elements were considered. This initial animation pass established every movement, expression, camera transition and transformation in the film. The later digital stages never replaced this performance; they were constructed directly upon it.

This production order follows one of the central ideas of classical cel animation. During most of the twentieth century, studios such as Disney, Fleischer, Warner Bros., UPA and the National Film Board of Canada separated animation into successive departments. Animators first established movement through pencil drawings. Clean-up artists refined the linework. Ink and paint departments transferred the drawings onto transparent cels before colour was added. Finally, the completed cels were photographed over painted backgrounds. Every later stage depended upon decisions already made by the animator.

Bread Will Walk preserves this hierarchy despite replacing acetate cels with digital compositing. The drawing remained the master document. Colour, texture, photographic collage, lighting and compositing all entered only after the animation itself had already been completed. In this sense, Photoshop functioned less as a painting program than as a contemporary equivalent of the historical ink-and-paint department.

Another principle inherited from traditional animation is the importance of line.

Classical character animation has historically depended upon expressive draftsmanship rather than surface rendering. Animators from Winsor McCay, Émile Cohl, Walt Disney, Hayao Miyazaki, Frédéric Back and Norman McLaren each approached line differently, yet movement consistently originated from drawing instead of texture. Bread Will Walk adopts the same philosophy. Even after photographic bread textures were introduced, the illusion of movement continued to originate from changing ink lines rather than photographic manipulation.

The decision to incorporate real bread photography emerged from an observation about bread itself. According to Boya, baked bread possesses an irregular porous structure that could not be convincingly synthesized through illustration alone. Rather than attempting to imitate this surface with painted textures, production experimented with incorporating photographs of actual bread into the drawings. The objective was not photorealism but material authenticity. The bread appearing on screen contains the visual complexity of genuine baked crust while remaining subordinate to the underlying animation.

The production briefly explored an entirely different direction through stop-motion animation. Tests were conducted using handmade and three-dimensional printed bread assets, and discussions even considered constructing a miniature oven equipped for pixilation photography inside the National Film Board. These experiments were ultimately abandoned because they introduced practical difficulties, including safety concerns, while also shifting attention away from the expressive qualities of drawing. The project therefore returned to the light table, reaffirming hand-drawn animation as its primary language.

This willingness to experiment before returning to drawing reflects another longstanding tradition within the National Film Board of Canada.

Since the 1940s, the NFB has functioned less as a house style than as an animation laboratory. Norman McLaren developed techniques by scratching directly onto film stock, painting individual frames and manipulating optical printers. Caroline Leaf animated directly in sand and paint beneath glass. Jacques Drouin refined the pinscreen originally developed by Alexandre Alexeïeff and Claire Parker. Frédéric Back combined coloured pencil with translucent layering. Rather than standardizing production, the NFB has historically encouraged filmmakers to invent techniques specifically suited to individual projects.

Producer Jelena Popović described the four-year development of Bread Will Walk as a continual process of “kneading” animation itself, comparing the evolving production to bread making rather than industrial manufacture. This metaphor extended beyond the subject matter of the film and became an accurate description of the production process: successive layers were repeatedly added, folded back, reworked and refined over several years instead of following a fixed industrial pipeline.

The production also experimented with three-dimensional environments. Early tests explored Unity-based virtual spaces and digitally navigated backgrounds capable of supporting the film’s continuous-shot structure. Although technically successful, these experiments were eventually rejected because they introduced unnecessary complexity while distancing the project from its hand-drawn foundation. The final production instead maintained a predominantly two-dimensional workflow in which spatial continuity emerged through drawing rather than simulated camera movement.

This decision reflects another historical characteristic of traditional animation.

Before digital three-dimensional software became widespread, animated camera movement was generally achieved through draftsmanship, multiplane photography, perspective construction and carefully staged background transitions rather than virtual geometry. Even films celebrated for their spatial complexity, such as Disney’s The Old Mill (1937), depended primarily upon painted artwork combined with mechanical camera systems rather than digital models. Bread Will Walk similarly prioritizes illustrated space over computed space.

Perhaps the clearest connection to traditional animation appears in the treatment of the individual frame.

Norman McLaren famously observed that animation is not the art of drawings that move but “the art of movements that are drawn,” emphasizing that what occurs between successive frames is more important than the drawings themselves. During production, this principle repeatedly guided aesthetic decisions. Whenever digital processes threatened to overpower the illusion created by the hand-drawn animation, they were reconsidered or abandoned. The continuity of movement always remained the governing priority.

This philosophy became especially apparent during experiments with AI-assisted tools. Certain internally developed systems generated textures, lighting references and isolated visual elements, yet these outputs consistently remained subordinate to manual intervention. Rather than accepting generated imagery as finished artwork, the production used these materials as references over which Boya redrew and repainted individual frames by hand. According to the NFB production notes, this approach preserved the unpredictability and intentionality of drawing while avoiding statistical visual uniformity.

The final appearance of the film therefore emerged through accumulation rather than replacement.

After the initial animation, every drawing underwent segmentation into separate visual regions such as skin, clothing, architecture and bread. Photographic textures were selectively introduced. Additional hand-painted interventions refined these surfaces frame by frame. Finally, English Animation Unit Technical Director Mathieu Tremblay assembled multiple rendered versions inside After Effects, blending linework, grain, texture and tonal information through what the production informally referred to as a “pastry glaze.” Rather than hiding the handmade qualities of the drawings, this final compositing stage unified them while preserving their visible construction.

A mark can behave like a musical phrase

In Begone Dull Care, Evelyn Lambart and Norman McLaren painted and engraved directly on film to create visual movement with the music of the Oscar Peterson Trio. It is a different method from drawing on paper and photographing or scanning the results. The comparison is useful precisely because handmade animation is not one technique: the material, the interval and the relation to sound can each be organised differently.

For a reading of Bread Will Walk, this opens attention to timing as part of the image rather than an addition to it. A changing surface is experienced through duration; a continuous movement can accumulate pressure without a cut. The discussion of painting and orchestral structure in Danse Macabre extends that question into contemporary animation. The shared inquiry is how material marks become an experience unfolding in time, not whether the films use the same workflow.

The resulting workflow illustrates a broader historical continuity within animation.

Throughout the twentieth century, each major technological development—from synchronized sound and Technicolor to xerography, digital ink-and-paint and computer compositing—initially appeared capable of replacing traditional drawing. In practice, many of these innovations instead expanded what hand-drawn animation could accomplish without eliminating its central role. Bread Will Walk follows this same trajectory. Photography, digital compositing, image processing and contemporary software all contribute to the finished image, yet every stage ultimately remains anchored by thousands of hand-drawn drawings completed at the light table.

In this respect, the production resembles traditional cel animation not because it reproduces historical manufacturing methods exactly, but because it preserves their fundamental creative order. The drawing remains primary. Every subsequent technological intervention exists in service of that original animated performance rather than replacing it.

From the visual notebook

Drawings, photographs and process material from The MILL’s public Facebook archive extend the visual questions explored here. This selection spans different projects and occasions; each original post remains linked for its own context and credits.

Inside the working studio

Inside the working studio — archive image 1
Inside the working studio · 1 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 2
Inside the working studio · 2 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 3
Inside the working studio · 3 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 4
Inside the working studio · 4 · Original post and context
Explore 8 more archive images
Inside the working studio — archive image 5
Inside the working studio · 5 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 6
Inside the working studio · 6 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 7
Inside the working studio · 7 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 8
Inside the working studio · 8 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 9
Inside the working studio · 9 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 10
Inside the working studio · 10 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 11
Inside the working studio · 11 · Original post and context
Inside the working studio — archive image 12
Inside the working studio · 12 · Original post and context